Ashkenazi beef, bean, and barley cholent
The centerpiece of the Shabbat meal: a slow-cooked beef stew with potatoes, beans, barley, and eggs, cooked all night in the oven alongside a kishke and g…
Cholent is the traditional Shabbat dish of Ashkenazi Jewish communities, which is prepared before Shabbat begins. It is cooked all night until it becomes very soft.
Ingredients and directions
- Prep time45 min
- Cook time12 hr
- Resting8 hr
- Total20 hr 45 min
- DifficultyHard
- CostModerate
- Cooking methodfour
- Estimated cost$25.66 $3.21 / serving Estimated price; varies by store. Converted from euros at the ECB rate of October 7, 2026.
Ingredients
people
Cholent
- $16.64
- $2.31
- $2.79
- $0.84
- $1.15
- $0.15
- $0.16
- $0.08
- $0.28
- $0.34
Jelly
- $0.08
- $0.05
- $0.35
- $0.08
- $0.08
- $0.28
Prices from US supermarkets for 12 of 16 ingredients; Belgian prices for the rest.
Directions
- The day before, soak the beans and barley in cold water overnight. This will soften them and make them easier to digest. Thaw the kishke in the refrigerator.
- Chop the onion and place it in a large oven-safe pot with a little oil.
- Place the whole apples on top of the onion in a single layer, then place the meat on top, and pour in the drained beans and barley. If there are any remaining apples, add a second layer. ≈ 3 min
- Pour, boiling water until it reaches three-quarters of the way up the ingredients. Season with salt, black pepper, and garlic.
- Bring to a boil and cook for about 30 minutes. Add the hard-boiled eggs, then gently pierce the kishke with a fork to prevent it from bursting.
- Prepare the kugel: finely chop the half-onion, add the crushed garlic, egg, and flour, salt, pepper, and mix well. Depending on the desired texture, add water or flour, mixing to prevent lumps. ≈ 8 min
- Sprinkle the kugel mixture over the cholent and continue to bake for 10 to 20 minutes.
- Preheat the oven to 150 °C and place the pot in the oven. After 1.5 to 2 hours, check the liquid level: it should have reduced to about one-third of the original height. If not, add more boiling water. Taste and adjust the seasoning as needed.
- Reduce the oven temperature to 90-100 °C and let it bake overnight.
The bill
Ashkenazi beef, bean, and barley cholent
- 1 kg of beef for braising (such as chuck or shin, with bones if possible)$16.64
- 8 medium-sized potatoes$2.31
- 8 hard-boiled eggs, peeled$2.79
- 250 g of dried navy beans$0.84
- 250 g of pearl barley$1.15
- 1 onion$0.15
- 3 cloves of garlic$0.16
- salt$0.08
- black pepper$0.28
- oil-based paint$0.34
- Half a small onion$0.08
- 1 clove of garlic$0.05
- 1 egg$0.35
- 60 g of flour$0.08
- salt$0.08
- black pepper$0.28
Total$25.66
that's $3.21 per person
Estimated price; varies by store.
🎬 Have a video of this recipe? Suggest a YouTube link
✏️ A mistake, an idea for this recipe? Suggest a correction
Reviews (0)
Rate this recipe Be the first to rate it!
Have you tried this recipe? Sign in to leave your review and rating.
You need to be a member to suggest a correction. Sign up for free, or sign in: you will then be able to report a mistake or suggest an improvement, and Axelle will read it.
Create a free account Sign in
You will come straight back to this recipe afterwards.